Located in the heart of Orlando near Lake Cay, NYPD Pizza Lake Cay has become a go-to spot for pizza lovers who crave authentic New York-style flavors in a welcoming, laid-back setting. Whether you’re visiting the city or you’re a local looking for a dependable slice, NYPD Pizza delivers a combination of crisp thin crusts, rich tomato sauce, and perfectly melted cheese that hits the spot. The menu reflects the diversity of New York’s pizza heritage, and the ambiance brings a taste of the Big Apple right to Central Florida.
About NYPD Pizza Lake Cay
NYPD Pizza Lake Cay stands out for its commitment to quality ingredients and a traditional approach to pizza making. The pizzeria pays homage to New York’s iconic pizza parlors, using hand-tossed dough, house-made sauces, and 100% real mozzarella cheese. The décor complements the theme with vintage NYC memorabilia, black-and-white photos of the city, and a cozy layout perfect for families, friends, or solo diners.
Authentic New York Pizza Experience
What sets NYPD Pizza Lake Cay apart is its focus on replicating the true New York pizza experience. The crust is thin but sturdy enough to fold, and the flavor profile leans into savory, cheesy satisfaction. Guests often praise the consistency, noting that the pizzas are always served hot and cooked to perfection. The pizzeria also offers generous slices for those who want a quick bite without ordering an entire pie.
Pizza Menu Highlights
The NYPD Pizza menu is rich with variety. From traditional pies to gourmet specialties, there’s something for everyone. Here are some of the standout options:
- The Original Cheese Pizza: A classic with mozzarella and house tomato sauce, served in slices or whole pies.
- Five Boroughs: A meat lover’s dream with pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ground beef, and ham.
- Madison Square Garden: Packed with veggies like mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, and tomatoes.
- Queens Deluxe: Pepperoni, sausage, onions, and green peppers, offering a balanced combo of meat and veggies.
- Brooklyn Buffalo Chicken: Spicy buffalo chicken with ranch or blue cheese drizzle for extra flavor.
- Times Square Margherita: Fresh basil, tomatoes, and garlic over a mozzarella and olive oil base.
Custom Pizza Options
Customers can also build their own pizzas, selecting from a variety of crusts, sauces, cheeses, and toppings. This customization makes it easy for vegetarians, picky eaters, or anyone with dietary restrictions to enjoy a pie just the way they like it.
More Than Just Pizza
While pizza is the star of the show, NYPD Pizza Lake Cay also offers a broad range of other menu items to satisfy every craving. Whether you’re in the mood for pasta, sandwiches, or appetizers, there are plenty of options to explore.
Appetizers and Sides
- Garlic Knots: Soft, buttery knots served with marinara dipping sauce.
- Fried Mozzarella: Golden and crispy on the outside, with gooey cheese inside.
- Buffalo Wings: Available in various spice levels and served with ranch or blue cheese.
- Meatballs: House-made meatballs served in marinara and topped with melted cheese.
Pasta and Entrées
- Spaghetti with Marinara: A simple classic, with the option to add meatballs or sausage.
- Baked Ziti: A cheesy, oven-baked pasta dish packed with flavor.
- Chicken Parmesan: Breaded chicken breast topped with marinara and mozzarella, served over pasta.
Salads and Healthy Options
For lighter fare, the menu features fresh salads like Caesar, Garden, and Greek. Guests can add grilled chicken or anchovies for protein. The crisp greens and homemade dressings make these salads a great complement to heavier pizza dishes.
Subs and Sandwiches
Hot and cold subs are also available, including:
- Italian Sub: Ham, salami, pepperoni, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing.
- Meatball Parmesan Sub: Meatballs smothered in marinara and cheese, served warm on toasted bread.
- Philly Cheesesteak: Thinly sliced steak with onions, peppers, and melted cheese on a hoagie roll.
Desserts and Beverages
To complete the meal, NYPD Pizza Lake Cay also offers a few dessert options, including New York-style cheesecake and cannoli. For beverages, choose from fountain drinks, bottled sodas, iced tea, and beer or wine where available.
Kid-Friendly Options
The restaurant caters to families with children by offering kid-sized portions and mild flavors. Cheese slices, spaghetti with butter, and plain pasta are popular choices for young diners. High chairs and friendly service also help make it a comfortable space for families with kids.
Takeout, Delivery, and Catering
NYPD Pizza Lake Cay is not only a dine-in restaurant but also provides convenient takeout and delivery services. Whether you’re hosting a gathering at home or planning an office lunch, they offer catering options with party-sized pizzas, salad trays, and pasta pans. Their efficient packaging and delivery timing ensure that the food arrives hot and ready to serve.
Location and Accessibility
Situated close to the Lake Cay Commons shopping area, the restaurant is easily accessible from the Convention Center and many of Orlando’s top hotels. Ample parking and nearby attractions make it a convenient stop for both tourists and locals. The casual setting and friendly staff provide a relaxed dining experience any time of the day.
Customer Reviews and Reputation
Reviews frequently highlight the freshness of ingredients, generous portions, and authentic taste. Many visitors from New York even comment on how close the pizza tastes to what they remember from back home. Staff friendliness, clean dining areas, and fast service also receive consistent praise.
Why Visit NYPD Pizza Lake Cay?
If you’re in Orlando and searching for authentic New York-style pizza, NYPD Pizza Lake Cay delivers a slice of the city with unmatched quality. Whether you’re looking for a casual dinner, a place to bring the kids, or a late-night slice after a busy day at the convention center, this local gem has you covered. With an expansive menu, friendly service, and a cozy NYC-inspired atmosphere, it’s no wonder NYPD Pizza remains a favorite for so many in the area.